Plagiarism is the sincerest form of flattery

After years of waiting, someone has finally copied my work. They have used a nom de plume. Being copied, even by a fictitious entity, does not take away that warm fuzzy feeling of knowing that someone likes my work

as much as I do, maybe more.

I once wrote an article about a law firm being blessed by the Pope. You
can find it online here.  

It was accepted by a legal magazine for publication online. When I did not hear from them, I found that they had taken lines, which we clearly both thought funny, from my article and used them in their own piece as if they were their original work.

Moral rights or, as we the plagiarized like to say, “Moral, I know my Rights” provides for a right for you to be named if your work is copied, and to control the form of the work, but there are exceptions. Also, there is “reverse passing off”, which covers plagiarism.

The editor would not explain, apologize or print the article in full, but did take down the offending web page, and she offered a mention of my site in a “regular blog spot”, a sort of “plagiarize one, get one free” offer. It may be understandable that editors do not readily apologize, just as captains often do not go down with their ships.

Like many potential litigants, I hoped that there might be a copyright lawyer out there, even a fictitious one, who would share my angst and take my case as a matter of principle, i.e. for free. However, as a copyright lawyer myself, I realized that was just not going to happen. So, it was left to me to do what any red-blooded copyright lawyer would do; write an article and then advise myself as to the next step. I advised myself to accept the mention in their regular blog spot and to
get on with my life.
Don’t underestimate the power you have by telling a publication that they have used your work without permission. You can easily damage the credibility of the publication and/or ruin the reputation of the person responsible. Not only should you be very careful in exercising this power, as it can backfire seriously but be aware of the consequences of your action.




Extract from "Easy IP: How to use the Law to Protect you Money-Making Ideas" by Paul Brennan

Listen to this episode on the Law Podcast 




©  Paul Brennan 2010-2020. All rights reserved

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What’s in a name? Trade marks and the law

Image
Just as in horror movies when the hero decides to enter the spooky room at end of the hall there are plenty of people advising against “Do it Yourself” (“DIY”) trade marks. In fact, there is a whole industry of lawyers and trade mark agents advising against it. The fun of trade marks is that they stop your competitors copying the unique way you do something. In the case of Coca Cola this is quite understandable. In the case of the New Zealand ice cream seller who by registering a musical trade mark stopped their competitors playing Green Sleeves, it is a service to humanity. Who could not support Harley Davidson wishing to trade mark the Harley Davidson engine rumble? This could keep so many of those ageing imitators off our streets? When someone is considering whether or not to instruct a lawyer to register a trade mark on their behalf, they will probably take note of the government website, which is so invitingly user-friendly (always a dangerous sign). It offers a procedure which is...
Read more

The most popular podcasts

Image
  Over three years ago, Paul Brennan started  The Law ® podcast .  Since that time, the five most popular podcasts have been: The man with four lawyers Insolvent trading-is everybody at it? How far are you prepared to go? Winning not always a joyous experience Why read The Art of War Search for the Law ® podcast by Paul Brennan or  click here . It is on Apple, Spotify and many other platforms. The Law ® podcast - Short clips on legal topics with a quirky outlook, but of real, everyday application with wry humour and the odd belly laugh.   #podcast #law SPONSORED BY
Read more

Coping with the Wicked Step Mom in your life

Image
Why did Walt Disney not have something cheesy to say about Step Mothers? Answer: they are a thoroughly bad lot, that’s why. Luckily you decided not to marry again (yet) and although suspicious of the new lady in your life, your adult children have not been too hostile (yet). After three years or so, your minds will turn to making wills. She has no children and is prepared lovingly to give everything to you. You want to see her right but to look after your own children too. You decide to consider carefully what your children will want. Within seconds you guess, “everything”. She will want your home. You give it to her for the duration of her life and then it will go to your children. On your death your children will do the “math” and decide that “your lady” has at least 30 years to go and may see them out. She may make a court claim for full ownership of the house. This is either because she is, understandably, fearful about her future security or a bit of an old bag depending on who yo...
Read more